Why Some New Products Blow Up and Others Flop

What do hype, luck and timing have to do with the success of new products? Every year, thousands of new products hit the market and many disappear just as quickly. Some estimates suggest up to half of new products have failed. Yet every so often, a launch captures attention instantly.

Part of the answer is strategy. Successful launches often build anticipation long before the product is available. Consider Rhode’s viral lip phone case. Founder Hailey Bieber subtly teased the product on social media for months, allowing curiosity to grow organically. By the time the case officially launched, more than 200,000 people had already joined the waitlist. By creating hype, Bieber created a conversation, not just a product.

Other brands rely on partnerships and cultural moments. New Balance collaborated with baseball stars Shohei Ohtani and Francisco Lindor to create a new cleat and apparel collection timed around the excitement of baseball season. By connecting the product to athletes’ identities and fan communities, the brand turned equipment into storytelling.

Innovation can also come from surprising places. Some famous products were born from mistakes or constraints such as snack foods developed from leftover ingredients or everyday problems that sparked new ideas. Marketers sometimes call this “planned serendipity” and develop winning products by creating conditions where unexpected insights can become opportunities.

The lesson for marketing students is clear. A successful launch rarely happens by accident. It blends creativity, timing, cultural relevance and a deep understanding of the audience. But even with strong research and strategy, uncertainty always remains. The smartest marketers prepare carefully and leave just enough room for luck. The next breakthrough product might start with a complaint, a collaboration or even a simple idea that suddenly feels obvious to everyone.

Discussion Questions and Activities

  1. Why do you think anticipation and teasing strategies are so effective for new product launches? How do partnerships with celebrities, influencers, or athletes change consumer perception of a product?
  2. In what ways can mistakes or unexpected discoveries lead to successful innovations?
  3. Is luck truly part of marketing success, or does good strategy simply make luck more likely?
  4. Launch Detective. Have students research a recent product launch and analyze the marketing strategy behind it. Students can start by browsing new product coverage on sites like CNN-underscored. Ask them to identify, target audience, marketing channels used, influencers or partnerships involved, evidence of hype or anticipation.
  5. Fix the Failed Product. Provide students with examples of failed products (e.g., Google Glass, New Coke, etc.). In small groups, students redesign the launch strategy including pricing, positioning, messaging or timing to see if they could improve the outcome.
  6. Accidental Innovation Challenge. Ask students to list everyday frustrations they experience on campus, at work, or at home. Then have them brainstorm a product idea that could solve one of those problems. Each group pitches their concept and explains how they would launch it to students.

Sources: Atland, Rikka, Saguin, Jacqueline, Matarazzo (6 Mar 2026), Our favorite product releases this week: Ikea, Le Creuset, New Balance and more, CNN Underscored; Nairn, Andy (15 Jul 2021), 7 ways to improve your new product development success rate, Ad Age; Weissman, Luna (13 Feb 2026) 5 Brands that Nailed New Product Launches, Launchmetrics.

Leave a comment

Filed under Classroom Activities

Cold, Custom, and Craving Attention: How Dutch Bros Wins Gen Z

When you think “coffee chain,” you might picture steaming lattes and cozy cafés. But Dutch Bros is flipping that script, and Gen Z is here for it. While giants like Starbucks and Dunkin’ still dominate overall market share, Dutch Bros has carved out a bold position by understanding and segmenting its audience with precision.

Gen Z doesn’t just like cold drinks; they identify with them. Studies from the National Coffee Association show that younger consumers are the most frequent iced and specialty beverage drinkers. Dutch Bros doubles down on that preference: roughly 90% of its drinks are served cold, colorful, and highly customizable. And customization is a positioning strategy, not a special order or afterthought for customers. By offering 40 plus flavors, boba add-ons, protein coffee innovations, and energy-drink mashups, Dutch Bros differentiates itself as the place where your drink is truly yours.

While competitors like McDonald’s see the trend and are is ramping up crafted cold beverages, Dutch Bros has built an identity around flavor play, social media energy, and loyalty-driven repeat visits. At the same time, its expansion into at-home products positions the brand in new retail segments and increases touchpoints beyond the drive-through.

This is segmentation and product positioning in action: understand your niche, own it, and build offerings that reinforce your identity at every turn.

Discussion Questions and Activities

  1. How does Dutch Bros use product customization to differentiate itself from competitors?
  2. Which Gen Z behaviors drive Dutch Bros’ product and marketing strategy? What risks come with expanding both physical stores and at-home retail products?
  3. How does brand positioning differ between Dutch Bros, McDonald’s and Starbucks?
  4. Why might cold beverages be more culturally appealing to Gen Z?
  5. Online Trend Hunt: Analyze current beverage trends using Google Trends and identify three rising flavor or drink styles. Link: https://trends.google.com
  6. Segmentation Breakdown. Create a profile for Gen Z beverage consumers using the four bases of segmentation including demographic, geographic, psychographic, and behavioral.
  7. Positioning Map: Plot Dutch Bros, Starbucks, Dunkin’, and McDonald’s and others on a perceptual map (e.g., customization vs. convenience).

Sources: Haddon, Heather (1 Mar 2026), The Third-Largest Coffee Chain in the U.S. Actually Sells Very Little Hot Coffee, Wall Street Journal; Nooranne, Sajil (2 Feb 2026), Dutch Bros Inc. (BROS) Positioned for Continued Same-Store Sales Momentum, Insider Monkey; Ericksen, Anne Baye (2 Feb 2026) Gen Z Drives the Cold Coffee Craze, C-Store Decisions.

Leave a comment

Filed under Classroom Activities

Nostalgia Economy

Have you’ve ever found yourself scrolling through “2016 vibes” edits on TikTok or feeling strangely emotional when you walk past a Build-A-Bear store? If so, congratulations! You’ve already participated in the nostalgia economy, one of the most powerful trends shaping marketing today. Marketers have long used nostalgia as a storytelling tool, but three recent trends show it’s becoming a full-blown strategy driven by data, culture, and economics.

First, brands like Build-A-Bear are rewriting the playbook. Nearly 30 years old, the company is now at record profitability, not by chasing kids, but by embracing you. Adults and teens are now a major part of their customer base, drawn in by sentimental memories and an experience that feels “safe” and hands-on compared to online shopping. This is nostalgia powered by experiential marketing, and it’s working.

But nostalgia isn’t just about reliving childhood fun. Gen Z’s obsession with “2016 vibes” is, at its core, a response to economic pressure and a more commercialized internet. When young adults say they miss 2016, they’re really missing a world that felt cheaper, freer, and less optimized for profit. In other words, nostalgia becomes a protest, and marketers who understand that emotional context can better interpret consumer behavior.

Finally, nostalgia is becoming intergenerational – driven by Millennial parents and Gen Alpha kids consuming media together. Brands are tapping into family nostalgia pipelines through school partnerships, retro product releases, and purpose-driven campaigns to cultivate loyalty that spans decades. In a world overloaded with data, nostalgia offers marketers something rare: a deeply emotional insight into why people buy, not just what they buy.

Discussion Questions and Activities

  1. Watch and discuss the Wall Street Journal’s video, How Build-A-Bear Found Success in the Nostalgia Economy. Why do you think nostalgia is especially powerful for Gen Z compared to other generations? In what ways can nostalgia be misused or lead to inaccurate conclusions in marketing research? Should brands actively encourage “kidulting,” or does it risk alienating younger consumers?
  2. How does the “2016 vibes” trend reveal insights that traditional surveys or focus groups might miss?
  3. How could data analytics help marketers predict future nostalgia trends?
  4. Trend Data Dive (Online Activity). Students analyze real-time nostalgia trends using TikTok Creative Center’s keyword analytics. Students search terms like “2016,” “aesthetic,” “throwback,” or a brand of their choice, then present what the data might indicate for marketers.
  5. Nostalgia Audit (Individual or Group). Students choose a brand and identify at least three ways it uses nostalgia. They must determine whether each tactic appeals to Gen Z, Millennials, or Gen Alpha, and discuss why.
  6. Build-A-Bear Strategy Redesign (Group Project). Students design a new nostalgia-driven experience or product offering for Build-A-Bear targeting college-aged consumers.

Sources:

Kranse, Jordan (28 January 2026), How Build-A-Bear Found Success in the Nostalgia Economy, Wall Street Journal Video Series; Lichtenberg, Nick and Roytburg, Eva (20 January 2026) Gen Z’s Nostalgia for ‘2016 vibes’ Reveals Something Deeper: a Protest Against the World and Economy They Inherited, Fortune; Mawhinney, Karl (19 December 2025), Why Nostalgia And Purpose Are The Next Frontier For Brand Loyalty, Forbes.

Leave a comment

Filed under Classroom Activities